Monthly Safety Scenario (MSS)
The Monthly Safety Scenario (MSS) is a Loss Prevention initiative to assist members in their efforts to comply with international safety regulations and to follow best practices.
The Club is publishing, every month, a new Monthly Safety Scenario (MSS) to assist owners in their efforts to comply with the above regulations. Alternative scenarios will be uploaded in SCOL. It is easy to download the MSS and enter the written conclusions from the meeting and send feedback to the shore-based organisation.
MSS Case December: Fall from bosun chair
It was morning and the bosun and three other ABs had planned to do some maintenance work in cargo hold 1.
The bosun began to scrape the parts he could reach from the tank top and also used an extension. After the 1000 coffee break the team returned to the cargo hold. As prior to the break the bosun had finished what he could from the tank top, he rigged up a ladder to reach further up. He was working in the aft starboard corner scraping and replacing the Ram-Nek sealant tape used to seal the space between the guide on the vessel’s side and the movable bulkhead. The other ABs were working on the other corners.
The bosun started to climb up a ladder, and the other ABs had their back to him. He was carrying a bosun chair, a roll of sealant and a hand scraper in his pocket. His plan was to scrape downward and apply the sealant. The deck gang heard a thud and when they turned around they could see the bosun lying on the tank-top on his back, the bosun chair and safety harness were lying by his legs. The hook on the bosun chair had broken and the bosun had fallen. He had not secured his safety harness.
One of the ABs climbed out of the hold and raised the alarm. The Master sounded the emergency alarm and mustered the emergency team by the hold. The crew managed to secure the bosun on a stretcher and take him to the vessel’s hospital. The bosun was bleeding from his head, ears and nose and had fractured his legs and right wrist. He was conscious and in great pain. The vessel made contact with the MRCC and a helicopter
was dispatched to the vessel. At this time the vessel was about 200 miles from land and it took the helicopter about four hours to arrive.
Questions
When discussing this case please consider that the
actions taken at the time made sense for all involved. Do
not only judge but also ask why you think these actions
were taken and could this happen on your vessel?
- What were the immediate causes of this accident?
- How could this accident have been prevented?
- What sections of our SMS would have been
breached, if any? - Is our SMS sufficient to prevent this kind of
accident? - If procedures were breached, why do you think this
was the case?
- Is there a risk that this kind of accident could
happen on our vessel? - How often do we check PPE?
- If we see someone not using the PPE correctly,
what are we supposed to do? - How could this accident have been prevented?
- Do we have a risk assessment on board that
addresses these risks? - Is there any kind of training that we should do
that addresses these issues? - What can we learn?
Download the case as PDF
MSS Case December: Fall from bosun chair
The bosun started to climb up a ladder, and the other ABs had their back to him. He was carrying a bosun chair, a roll of sealant and a hand scraper in his pocket. His plan was to scrape downward and apply the sealant.
Under the ISM requirement, owners are obliged to carry out monthly safety meetings or safety committee meetings onboard their vessels. This obligation stems from Chapter 5 of the ISM Code: “Master’s responsibility and authority” and furthermore from “5.1.2, motivating the crew in the observation of that policy”.
The obligation can also be derived from the Code of “Safe Working Practices for Merchant Seamen”, where it is stated that the safety committee should meet regularly: “3.13.2, The frequency of meetings will be determined by circumstances but as a general guideline, the committee should meet about every 4-6 weeks”.
For more Loss Prevention information, please contact:
Archive
(older scenarios are available in SCOL)